Showing posts with label Montana. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Montana. Show all posts

Thursday, February 17, 2011

Montana Senate votes to repeal death penalty

The state Senate is sending a bill to repeal Montana's death penalty to the House, where the plan failed 2 years ago.

A day after the Senate signaled its support for Senate Bill 185, the chamber gave it final passage Tuesday with another 26-24 vote. The bill drew the support of all the chamber's Democrats and 4 Republicans.

If it passes, the bill will immediately replace the death penalty with life in prison without parole and could change the sentences of 2 inmates currently on death row.

Next, the bill must clear the Republican-dominated House. A similar measure passed the Senate last session in 2009, but didn't even make it out of a House committee.

Source: Associated Press, Feb. 16, 2011
_________________________
Use the tags below or the search engine at the top of this page to find updates, older or related articles on this Website.

Wednesday, December 15, 2010

Canadian on Montana's death row gets indefinite reprieve

A high state court has granted the only Canadian on America's death row an indefinite reprieve from execution.

Ronald Allen Smith was scheduled to die by lethal injection Jan. 31, 2011 but the Montana Supreme Court ruled Tuesday a civil case that claims the method of execution constitutes "cruel and unusual punishment" must first be concluded.

"There will be no execution," Montana assistant Attorney General Mark Fowler told QMI Agency. "The stay will be in effect until the lethal injection case has been decided."

Tuesday's reprieve ruling comes after a battle between two judges over whether a civil case should delay a scheduled execution by the state. Fowler could not guess how long the civil case could take to go through trial and possible appeals.

Smith, an Alberta native, has exhausted all appeals against his conviction and death penalty. He pleaded guilty to the 1983 double murder of Thomas Running Rabbit and Harvey Mad Man, young aboriginal cousins from the Blackfeet nation, who were marched into a forest and shot in the back of the head.

Smith's civil case argues his constitutional rights are infringed by the potential for pain and suffering by administration of the lethal injection. It also maintains his rights to privacy and human dignity will be violated.

"While we understand Judge (John) Larson's concerns over the prospect of conflicting orders, the fact is that Mr. Smith's execution has "over the past 15 years" been stayed by various state and federal courts while those courts weighed the propriety of Mr. Smith's conviction and sentence. Such is the path of death penalty cases," reads the judgment.

Despite the ruling, Fowler said the state will continue to pursue the death penalty against Smith.

"There remains a valid conviction and death sentence but the state can not enforce that sentence right now," he said.

Source: Toronto Sun, December 14, 2010

Wednesday, December 8, 2010

Montana: Death penalty, physician-assisted suicide, same-sex couples bills planned for 2011 Legislature

Montana lawmakers soon will be considering bills to ban the death penalty and to allow or forbid physician-assisted suicide when a terminally ill patient requests it.

The 2011 Legislature also will take up a proposal to add sexual orientation and "gender identity and expression" to the state Human Rights Act and protect those classes of people from discrimination.

Niki Zupanic of ACLU Montana said many of the new legislators were swept in with the national sentiment for a smaller, limited government.

"We're hoping that sentiment will hold true on social issues as well," she said. "Things like a woman's right to choose, reproductive freedom and freedom for the lesbian, gay, bisexual and transgender community."

The ACLU again will be working to ban the death penalty in Montana. The Senate approved a ban in 2009, but it stalled in a House committee on a tied vote.

"On the issue of whether the state should continue to hold onto this broken system of holding onto the death penalty, it costs way too much, it doesn't work and it's a poor use of tax dollars," Zupanic said.

Sen. Ron Erickson, D-Missoula, will sponsor the bill to abolish the death penalty.

As for physician-assisted suicide, Rep. Dick Barrett, D-Missoula, is introducing legislation to implement a 2009 Montana Supreme Court decision to allow this procedure when a terminally ill patient requests it.

"My sense is that terminally ill Montanans really do want to have this choice available to them, not that large numbers of people take advantage of it," Barrett said when requesting the bill draft earlier this year.

"We'll be advocating for Montanans to continue to have access in aid in dying and to make those decisions with their doctor without government interference," Zupanic said.

Jeff Laszloffy, president of the Montana Family Foundation, said his group stands against physician-assisted suicide.

"I think one of the big ones we're really going to be fighting is the legalization of assisted suicide in Montana," he said.

Meanwhile, Sen. Greg Hinkle, R-Thompson Falls, is requesting a bill to ban physician-assisted suicide in Montana. He has referred to it as "elder abuse."

The Montana Human Rights Network will try to expand the state's Human Rights Act to include "sexual orientation and gender identity and expression," program director Kim Abbott said. Among other things, that would forbid employment discrimination against this group.

"It's adding those classes to the bedrock human rights law in Montana." Abbott said. "We were able to get protection at the local level in Missoula, so we're feeling good about the effort."

However, Abbott predicted it would be an uphill battle at the Legislature because of its makeup.

"We think it's important to give lesbian, gay, bisexual and transgender people a space to tell their story and for people who are elected leaders to hear them," she said.

Sen.-elect Tom Facey, D-Missoula, has asked for this bill to be drafted.

However, Laszloffy said the Montana Family Foundation will stand opposed to any attempts to protect homosexuals under the state's hate crime law, to allow homosexual couples to get same benefits as heterosexual couples and to authorize civil unions between same-sex couples.

"This is probably not the best session for that agenda, given the numbers in the House and Senate," he said.

Source: Missoulian, December 8, 2010